The Hobbit (book, not the movies): because it's a series of smaller but exciting adventures around a very peculiar character and because I like how the world and the fantastical creatures are presented through his eyes with awe, horror and wonder, instead of everything being taken for granted or as trivial. I also enjoy the children's book / fairy tale tone of the narration. The Lord of the Rings is good, too, but to be honest, I mostly like the more small scale or personal parts that are either Hobbit-like or eerie, and less the epic parts that are supposedly more Silmarillion-inspired, the stories of human kingdoms and battles and great evil and such.
Astrid Lindgren's Ronja rövardotter, if that counts. I guess I just prefer fantasy settings to be explored with childlike wonder and relatable characters. I think I generally prefer children or young adult fantasy because to me it seems more imaginative and character-focused. I'm a sucker for fictional creatures and the eerie, too, and this book has both in good measure. Of course, I read both this and The Hobbit as a kid, they may have been my introduction to fantasy, so that might explain my preferences a bit as well. I haven't found a lot of adult fantasy that I would read with the same interest and enjoyment, sadly.
I guess Game of Thrones is a good one, too, but it's tricky to judge, as I only watched the show (without the last season) and didn't read the books, the official story of the novels isn't concluded yet and the series' conclusion, from what I've heard, seems rushed and in part badly written. What makes it good is how character-driven it is and that the characters are vulnerable and fallible. I don't really like heroic fantasy, I guess. GoT has this typical big evil threat plot, too, but it's more of a backdrop to all the characters' stories, the politics and intrigues. It's not a clear-cut good vs. evil epic.
I like (most of) the Discworld books by Terry Pratchett, too, but they went from parody of fantasy novels to parody (?) of our world and comparatively modern things, so they don't feel as much like 'serious' fantasy stories, whatever that is. And I enjoyed reading Harry Potter, but more so the first books when it was on a smaller scale and more personal than the later ones where it became a bit of that typical epic battle of good vs. evil nonsense with wizard ex machina twists again.
I fear that's it, for the most part. Not a very original list. I haven't tried that many different adult fantasy novels, but when I've tried some they seldom managed to draw me in and hold my interest. I'm rather put off by epic tales in lands where everything seems kind of familiar but has silly new names and draws heavily from Tolkien, D&D or other overused tropes. I don't really want to read about elves, dwarves and orcs anymore (or about [insert new names for elves, dwarves and orcs here]). I'm very aware that those are heavy prejudices that might not be true for a greater part of fantasy novels, but still, I haven't really found a lot to convince me that fantasy novels can be as much fun as I would like them to be.
Oh, Rumo, by Walter Moers was a good one, too, IIRC. But the books by Walter Moers aren't dead serious, and his new silly fantasy names are often funny and don't sound as far-fetched or alien at all in German. The novels also have a bit of that light children's book tone, even though Rumo is pretty brutal at times.
Post edited June 06, 2019 by Leroux