Before I say anything, you should know I have NOT played either of these games.
Personally, I would go with Pyre.
Wizard of Legend (WoL from now) looks to be very good, but another twin stick shoot em up rogue lite. I'm not saying that is a bad thing, but there are so many of those available and there will probably be more to come.
Pyre on the other hand looks unique in it's 'battles' or whatever they are. Also nice visuals. To me in the similar vain as Transistor, very stylish. Doesn't look like it was made in Flash in like 2008.
Although I will say that if you want replayability, WoL might be better with it builds and stuff.
Some end points.
Pyre
- Unique battles, video
here - Slick visuals
- Possibly more story???
- Looks more interesting and new to me
WoL
- More action heavy
- More replayability
- The usual pixel graphics, not a bad thing per se
- Common gameplay (Gungeon, Isaac)
This may make you more confused as to which to buy, but my point goes to Pyre.
Also oranges > apples. Fight me.