Ha, you're genius! I thought it was more of an intrinsic riddle, something relating to the content and not an extrinsic riddle where it's about something like "they were all released in the same month" or as you so smartly observed, the 4th in a series.
Interesting how differently everyone's brain works.

But I would be strangely surprised if your answer was the one tinyE is looking for here

He said "The Revenge" so I highly doubt it relates to the TV series "Revenge"

Revenge had me for a minute, as there is a seinfeld and matlock episodes with that name, but nothing related to 4th. However, I may not be right, we'll have to see.
Oh poop. Well, I thought I had something going... Oh well....

I believe tinyE is referring to this song:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nhvDzyfovh8

(The Revenge by Caliban)

[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaws:_The_Revenge]Jaws: The Revenge[/url]?

CREWDROOG FOR THE WIN!!!

I will PM your code shortly! :D
Though technically with Revenge I was referring to the 4th Jaws movie, but this works. XD

Ah! Phew, I already thought Crewdroog's guess wouldn't work and it would be something extremely complicated and deeply psychologicalabout the lyrics (all the names on your list could have been referring to songs/albums).

Anyway, congrats to Crewdroog for saving us all from overanalyzing this one!

EDIT: this is exactly why I always get stuck in adventure games, the answer is always much more straight to the point than I thought. So frustrate!

Jaws, of course!
Hooray! Thanks TinyE. I've been wanting to play postal (dont you all judge me ;) ). It is just the kind of high-brow adventure game that my library so desperately needs. :)

congrats again on hitting 1000, and I like your festive hat, it matches your skin.

Congrats and nice work, Crewdroog!

And congrats to tinyE on your promotion.

2112 was the fourth album by Rush also.

Congrats Crewdog :)