Sogi-Ya: It is funny that Ridley Scott is the father of the "Director Cut" with the re-edit of Blade Runner, but he hates them.
I find it funny that FOX tried to force him into doing a director's cut with Prometheus; so he gave then a theatrical version that cut tons of quality content that would have vastly improved the film ... it was clearly just beging for a Director's Cut.
Then he flat refused to re-edit it back in for the DVD version and fuck over FOX on all the DC money they were expecting.
MrLongPants: Don't know if that's fact or speculation.
But it sucks if its true.
It is.
Ever since Blade Runner DC, FOX has been making him produce inferior cuts for the theaters and then pushing for the real version he wanted on the retail release; essentially the same thing that Peter Jackson was intentionally does with his movies, except that Scott hates it.
If you watch the DC version of Kingdom Of Heaven, it is an epic story full of depth and hard truths about the formation of the middle east and the roots of European power ... every scene that was edited back into the movie was critical plot development and none of them were unfinished work or just an alternate angle; they were finished scenes that were made to be in the film and FOX made him cut them to trim for length, dumb down the complexity of the movie, and to contrive material for a director's cut.
With gladiator they didn't make him cut things that he wanted in, but they made him put out a DC version for disk.
With Kingdom Of Heaven they made him cut things, and he wanted to release the real version as much as they wanted a DC.
With Robin Hood they fucked with the basic story be wanted to do (it was supposed to be about the Sheriff of Nottingham, with Robin portrayed as the villain) so he didn't really care when the made him do cuts again, and everything that he pulled for the DC was inconsequential to the story.
When they tried pulling the same shit with Prometheus, he gave them the shitty version they wanted for theaters but then flat refused to do a DC to fuck them over on the retail version in hopes that they would knock off the bullshit.