drealmer7: There's so many great moments in AoD, imo.
tinyE: I think that's valid. The reason I just don't think it works is because it's tied to the other two. Evil Dead 1 & 2 are relentless not stop over the top blood fest that take no quarter and offer no apologies and AoD is almost an action comedy. I have nothing against action comedy, in fact I love action comedy, I just don't think one belongs in that trilogy.
I understand, they've got different flavors, certainly. I think different genres can still be in the same series, though, it just mixes it up. They just went there with it with the base material they had, I think 2 is a good bridge between them as well. 1=straight horror. 2=comedy horror. 3=action comedy fantasy horror. It is ballsy though, considering fans usually want more of the same, so I understand.
Part of it for me too is that I had no idea Army of Darkness was related to the Evil Dead movies until a while AFTER I saw Army of Darkness. When I was a pre-teen at the video store, I stayed away from the Evil Dead movies, but Army of Darkness on the shelf always appealed, and so when I turned 13 and was "old enough" I rented Army of Darkness, and loved it. Then when I was 16 I worked up the courage to rent Evil Dead, and was like "OH WHAT?!?!?! They're part of the same series?!?!"
I couldn't watch/rent Evil Dead 2 fast enough after that realization, and then it all came together with the portal opening and all that. I was blown away.