And I've started The Witcher (first one); probably this is the third time starting it, but I have a good feeling about this playthrough. Among other things, I'm playing it on my laptop, which automatically makes a game about ten times more likely to be finished, since I spend so little time in my apartment. Still in Chapter 1; a few preliminary thoughts:
1. I am not loving how this game controls, which might be because laptop trackpads were never designed to be gamed with, or might just be because it doesn't control great.
2. Not really feeling the combat, maybe partly because of (1). The different "combat styles" seem kind of pointless, since whether it's fast, strong, or group, you're still just rhythmically clicking.
3. The writing is bad. Sorry. I know it used to be worse before the Enhanced Edition, but it's still wooden and ridiculous. "They're [I]evil[/I] dogs!"
4. I (as a player) have basically no motivation. I barely know what these stolen mutigens [I]are[/I], and I exchanged about five sentences with what's-his-name before he snuffed it. Come to think of it, thanks to the amnesia plot device, Geralt is in basically the same boat, motivation-wide. He also doesn't know what mutigens are, and only new dead-guy two days.
5. Amnesia is a cheap plot device.
So those are basically negative so far. However, it's early days, and I'm going to give it a fair chance to wow me with these "tough choices that actually matter" that it supposedly features.