iippo: Free roaming is not some instant win in my opinion.
I-War 2 is very good game and i liked it, but didnt really care for the sandbox part of it as its precisely that - shallow sandbox. Beatiful scenery, but other than thats you just grind the transporters never mind the system you are in.
Meanwhile, I-War 1 told way more interesting stody (in my opinion) with so good and surprising missions twists the they have not been since.
Did you know that the mission could be succesful, even when you didnt complete it anywhere near 100%? The debriefings would vary greatly depending on what you did or did not do - and oh my got that stuff was creative.
Its ofcourse just my opinion, but i do like to take good story and creative, surprising missions over your regular sandbox game any day of the week. Also while equiping your ship is fun - its just one part of the game, not something that "makes the game by itself".
Would mind if I-War 3 came along...
I found the sandbox rather good even though there was little to do outside pirating, I have yet to see a game where in I can stalk a freighter convoy and ambush them in deepspace.
The story of I-War 1, although well told, I found rather predictable to be honest, though I admit that it was better than the cut short story of I-War 2.
By the way, I found Star Wolves surprisingly good and I was admittedly addicted to it to see it through the end.