Thanks for posting this! I was going to get to it if you hadn't. Definitely deserves more votes and attention. Get it GOG!

<span class="bold">Singles: Flirt Up Your Life!</span>   ( © 2004 Rotobee Realtime 3D  ―  Currently 32 votes )
 
 
Singles: Flirt Up Your Life is a relationship simulator.  Think "The Sims" on a much smaller scale but with a more detailed character interaction.

The game starts of by giving you 2 couples who live in a flat.  Your task is to explore their relationship while controlling their tasks like cooking, watching TV and a whole lot more.  The couples will fight with each like in real life too.  Then there are moments where the couples will get intimate with each other.  This where the fun starts as players are given a few levels of eroticism to play with.  Starting from mild kissing up to making love or having a shower together.
 
 
 ▪  <span class="bold">Wishlist entry</span>
 ▪  <span class="bold">MobyGames page</span>
 ▪  <span class="bold">Gameplay video</span>

http://www.gog.com/forum/general/we_need_more_classic_ea_titles/post24

Found it!

This would be great!!!!!!!

Shark Attack Deathmatch 2 on Steam. It really is a very good game, has like a 97% positive rating on steam and has the best Shark AI in any game I have played. Is Player v Player v AI controlled sharks. Also has a horde style survival mode, but still early in development, buy what is there is really well done, but sadly has a really poor playerbase.

Please follow the rules. ;-)

1.  Choose a game pre 2005 (including the year 2005) with less than 350 votes on the community wishlist and mention the current number of votes.

Oh god no, couldn't do that. Who wants to play 10 year old games?

<span class="bold">Safecracker</span>   ( © 1997 Daydream Software  ―  Currently 41 votes )
 
 
As the name implies, this game is all about cracking safes.  Within an eccentric millionaire's luxurious mansion, thirty-five safes in all sizes, shapes and colors are hidden.  As an applicant for the position of Security Development Chief, you must prove your worthiness by locating and opening every one of the mansion's safes without getting caught by security.

Safecracker is a puzzle game within a graphical setting.  Exercise your brain cells and challenge your powers of logic and deduction while solving its mind-bending puzzles.  Are you good enough to crack the Granddaddy of all safes?
 
 
 ▪  <span class="bold">Wishlist entry</span>
 ▪  <span class="bold">MobyGames page</span>
 ▪  <span class="bold">Gameplay video</span>
 

Whoa, Submarine Titans was doing pretty well when I was away. It should reach 350 votes soon...

http://www.gog.com/wishlist/games/cybermage_darklight_awakening

Cybermage: Darklight Awakening.

That's a really good game, but it currently has 440 votes.  You need to post games with less than 350 votes.  ;-)

<span class="bold">Stupid Invaders</span>   ( © 2001 Xilam  ―  Currently 107 votes )
 
 
Five aliens crash-land on Earth, and hide out in an abandoned house while they repair their spaceship.  In the meantime, Dr Sakarin, an evil alien-collecting scientist has found out about them, and sends out his evil henchman Bolok to capture them.  The player alternates between controlling each of the five aliens, and must help them escape.

Stupid Invaders is based on the animated TV series Space Goofs.  The player interacts with the environment in a point-and-click fashion.  Up to six items can be carried simultaneously and used to solve puzzles.  Many actions lead to instant death of the protagonist, often graphically depicted and used for the humorous effect of cartoon violence.
 
 
 ▪  <span class="bold">Wishlist entry</span>
 ▪  <span class="bold">MobyGames page</span>
 ▪  <span class="bold">Adventure Gamers' review</span>
 ▪  <span class="bold">Gameplay video</span>
 

<span class="bold">Bone: Out from Boneville</span>   ( © 2005 Telltale Games  ―  Currently 100 votes )
 
 
Bone: Out From Boneville is the first graphic adventure title released by Telltale Games, a company founded by former LucasArts employees.  Out From Boneville is based on the identically named comic book created by Jeff Smith, and it's the first installment in the episodic Bone game series.

The game follows exactly the plot of the book, namely it begins with the introduction of cousins Fone, Phone, and Smiley Bone, who are lost in the desert after they fled their hometown Boneville.  Their goal is to get back to Boneville, but due to several twists of fate their journey takes them to other places.

Using a traditional 3D point-and-click interface, the player must guide the three cousins through all quests, where they meet the red dragon, the rat creatures, Ted the bug, the possum kids, Thorn and Gran'ma Ben.
 
 
 ▪  <span class="bold">Wishlist entry</span>
 ▪  <span class="bold">MobyGames page</span>
 ▪  <span class="bold">Adventure Gamers' review</span>
 ▪  <span class="bold">Gameplay video</span>
 
 
NOTE:  A duplicate wishlist entry exists, with only <span class="bold">29 votes</span>.
 

No Greater Glory
Currently 15 votes

Maybe not a big game in anywhere but the United States of America, seeing as it's a (USA) Civil War game, but I had hundreds of hours of fun with it as a teen. You play as either North or South, you select your cabinet, select policies, tax rates, etc. You spend funds on infrastructure, you raise troops and make boats. You do what you can to keep your people loyal and most importantly and fun you move your armies on a map and take the enemy city by city. General selection is important, a great general can win a battle you should loose and vice-versa. Make sure you have enough supplies or else attrition will kill you more than any bullet would! It's a fun game and deserves more than 15 little votes.

Vote for it HERE

Novastorm- 48 votes

https://www.gog.com/wishlist/games/novastorm

A spaceship shooter that plays a lot like Star Fox. It's interesting because the PC, PS1 and Sega CD versions of the game are all a little bit different than one another.

Traffic Giant / Verkehrsgigant - 57 votes

https://www.gog.com/wishlist/games/traffic_giant_verkehrsgigant

This game is probably the spiritual predecessor of Cities in Motion. Like in Cities in Motion you manage a public transportation company and need to set up bus, tram or train lines to reduce the traffic in big cities or a bunch of small towns. The game has some sort of a campaign and a free mode. There is also a gold edition with more maps and missions.
The biggest problem here will be that JoWood was the developer and publisher of the game.