hedwards: People say that, and it's BS. The reason why polygamy and polygyny are typically illegal is because it ensures that a portion of the population can't get married.
Vestin: Sounds to me like we're rationing people... to people.
"Oh, you're an item now, are you? ONE ITEM PER HOUSEHOLD :|!"
It's not rationing, it means that everybody has the possibility of spending the rest of their lives with somebody. OK, perhaps not everybody, but it's far more likely than if people are allowed to multtiple people.
Also, you're smarter than this. This is an asinine argument to make.
hedwards: What's more, cultures that have polygamy don't always have rules that require the person marrying multiple people to be capable of supporting all of them.
Vestin: In some cultures they don't even support the single one they can marry ;P.
Also - it's not like only a single party in a marriage must be responsible for the income...
Must be nice to live in a rich country. I've never met anybody in America that could afford to have one person just sitting around all day doing nothing while the help does everything. In most cases the home maker is actually doing a lot of work, far more than what she would have to do at a job.
hedwards: Multiple marriage itself is something that has very real problems associated with it in the same way that marrying children off to adults has inherent problems.
Vestin: I don't disagree, but is this enough to legally limit people in how they live their lives?
From a detached, logical standpoint, one might as well claim that childbearing isn't necessarily something everyone should be involved in, as it can do more harm than good to the society as a whole. In spite of this - we don't very much regulate human reproduction, leaving it up to the individuals. Where do you draw the line, and why does it happen to conveniently be around where our current cultural customs end ;)? Of course - I'm not saying it should be complete anarchy...
As a side note - perhaps we could use more media depiction of polygamy or more instances of it in games. If for nothing else - for flavor and variety...
Yes, absolutely it is. People who need more than one person can just not get married. Some people do have issues settling down with one person, but for those folks I can't think of any good reason why they should even bother with marrying in the first place. Seems to me like they'd be better off just dating for the rest of their lives. At virtually any age there are single people out there for dating. I don't think it becomes an issue until way far down the road.